Noise induced hearing loss – Disease or not?

Noise induced hearing loss – Disease or not?

Mr Justice Phillips handed down judgment in the cases of Dalton and Others v BT Plc on the preliminary issue as to whether NIHL/Tinnitus is to be treated as an injury or a disease for the purposes of calculating fixed success fees under the former part 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

In making his decision he considered a lot of extraneous material, including the provisions of the social security legislation which, did contain an extended definition of disease.

Regulations made under the 1975 Act, the Social Security (Industrial Injuries) (Prescribed Diseases) Regulations 1985, which remain in force, define prescribed diseases as “a disease or injury described under … these regulations, and references to a prescribed disease being contracted shall be deemed to include references to a prescribed injury being received”. Schedule1 lists prescribed diseases, including: “A10 Substantial sensoineural hearing loss (occupational deafness)”. Occupational deafness is defined in the Regulations as “the disease numbered A10 in part one of schedule 1 to these regulations”.

It follows that NIHL has been expressly defined as a ‘disease’ in subordinate legislation governing statutory compensation for industrial injuries for about 30 years and had been so defined about 20 years prior to the introduction of section V of CPR Part 45 in 2005.

Therefore, he found that NIHL/Tinnitus is a disease rather than an injury, and the higher success fees applicable to diseases should apply.

The defendants have made an application to appeal.

Plainly, this is a much welcome judgment for the claimants and their legal advisors.

Latest News

Melanie Cotterill Explains the Benefits of Lasting Powers of Attorney

Make sure you have a voice in later life. In life we are all encouraged to speak our minds and be masters of our own…

More

Equality and Diversity

We survey our people as required by the Solicitors Regulatory Authority and the statistics from the last survey can be found here.

More

Noise induced hearing loss – Disease or not?

Mr Justice Phillips handed down judgment in the cases of Dalton and Others v BT Plc on the preliminary issue as to whether NIHL/Tinnitus is…

More

Update on success fees on noise induced hearing loss claims

Submissions concluded today before Mr Justice Phillips in Birmingham, on the point as to whether NIHL/tinnitus is a disease or injury for the purposes of…

More
Interested in a claim? Contact us now! 01752 546448 Make an appointment